Thanks a lot for the mod, there were some disagreements but thats solely because of the experimental mapping style I'm using.KanaRin wrote: 5k3967
Let's go.
General
Mod info:
KAT / K = Blue note ( Big DON/KAT = Big notes)
DON / D= Red note
Futsuu
- I think the volume of hitsound is a bit quite low, especially kiai time. How about increase to 90%? - okay!
- Inappropriate diff spread, you must at least add a Muzukashii here. - I asked around about this kind of diff spread in #taiko, and a got a few saying its should be acceptable depending on how the diffs are constructed. Risky move, I know, but the Futsuu here is a bit challenging for Futsuu, but still too easy for Muzukashii, whilst Oni is very authentic and simple-esk. It creates a good balance in my opinion. I'll ask around more and see what people think.
- Nice.
Oni
That's it. Overall that should be ready to go.
- ＊00:15:157 (2) - d sounds better as we can hear the ing sounds is dkdkd easily. - okay
- ＊00:15:407 - so yeah, add a don here! - nah, I want to keep a somewhat consistent rhythmical pattern.
- 00:16:490 (1) - Start from here is the same as ^ , make dkdkd here. - I made the triplet a dkd instead of having 5 notes.
- That means you should change 00:16:573 (2) - to kat and add a kat at 00:16:740 - ^
- 00:43:323 (8,9,10,11) - kk kk sounds better here. - Changed to kk kd instead, to keep the Big Kat.
- 00:43:823 (12) - as I can hear bass drum, I suggest you use big don here, so the pattern here is kk kk D. - I'm mostly following piano for this part, so I want to keep this a Large Kat since the piano is higher pitch than the previous note.
- 01:14:990 (2) - Start from here, I strongly suggest you to follow the drums as it's really obvious. - I don't understand quite what you mean, but the map follows the drum mostly on that part.
- 01:15:323 (6) - d is better here as the small drum is End. - nah, I transitioned into following the drill sound which goes k d k d.
- 01:15:490 (7) - k , small drum. - Following drill, ^
- 01:15:573 - add a k here. - That works since it follows the drill well as well as a drum you want me to follow.
- 01:15:657 (1) - finally, here is d. - Nah, following the drill as stated previously.
- 01:17:323 (5,1,2) - better to use dkd here. - nah, ddk is a good way to transition into the smoothened (idk what you call it) snare sounds.
- 01:36:323 (3) - kat. --- ( for that part it sounds weird if you miss drums, I will suggest the following patterns) - that works so well because it fits the piano.
- 01:36:490 - add a don here - sure, it blends in well with the piano.
- 01:36:573 - and then add a kat here. - no thanks, I am not trying to majorly follow drums on this part.
- 01:36:990 - kat. - sorry, no can do because following piano for most part, would make the next kat sound awkward ;;
- 01:47:323 (7,8,9,10,1) - Same, kk kk D. - Fixed in the same way as before.
- 01:48:657 (5) - miss a don here. - sure, works well with the piano.
- 02:02:823 (7) - That part must have some more improvement.
I have a disagreement with happy30 here, I think you better to follow the drums here because the piano beat is really chaotic. It's not suitable for Taiko map. -
Maybe you can try to remap that part with your own first. [/color]- 02:12:990 (3,4,5,6,1,2,3,4,1) - 1/3 xxxooox. - Did this instead, http://puu.sh/47tkg.jpg You can hear that last bit is a 1/4 if you listen closely.
The only problem is the last part and the diff spread, maybe you can get some more suggestions from other modder.
call me back when you think that's good enough.
I want to hear about other people's opinions on a F+O Diff Spread, its technically rankable but again; risky.
If its a really large problem, I'll map a Muzukashii. (or at least try)
http://puu.sh/47tug.rar Updated Diffs here.
