Well, as this option was revealed recent and I found that this would make playing experience worse for DT/NC or HT/DC(Daycore) s. As this option exists for mapsets which use full-hitsounds like BMS concept or piano concept mapsets but some mapper uses this even mapset doesn't have any custom hitsounds.

At then, it would play failback sounds from skin hitsounds and they are purposed as played with x1.00 speed.

I searched RC but there's no rule related with this option so modder cannot post as problem which makes playing experience worse.



So, I suggest to add rule related with this option into general playmodes(std, taiko, catch and mania) so mappers and modders can care about this and make playing experience as usual one.

definitely agree. surprising that it's not mentioned in RC at all yet

im not sure this happens enough to the point where it needs to be codified into rc, but it's definitely a strange thing when you run into a map that does this

i guess if it does happen enough then ye why not

i mean it doesnt matter how often it happens it shouldn't not be allowed under any circumstances no?

SaltyLucario wrote: 2r6s3u

i mean it doesnt matter how often it happens it shouldn't not be allowed under any circumstances no?

Only if mapset used custom hitsound like piano into NC mapset I guess

yeah i meant usage for non keysounded maps, mb

SaltyLucario wrote: 2r6s3u

i mean it doesnt matter how often it happens it shouldn't not be allowed under any circumstances no?

maybe; i just consider it more of an unwritten rule that "if you notice it you say something"

tbf, the less of those there are in the mapping scene, the better off we are probably

also should this be a rule? feel like its definitely more in guideline territory

The main question is to define keysounding.

I would fully banning usage of Samples match playback rate in Taiko, because it don't make sense there. No comment for other modes.

tilda wrote: 5n595f

SaltyLucario wrote: 2r6s3u

i mean it doesnt matter how often it happens it shouldn't not be allowed under any circumstances no?

maybe; i just consider it more of an unwritten rule that "if you notice it you say something"

tbf, the less of those there are in the mapping scene, the better off we are probably

also should this be a rule? feel like its definitely more in guideline territory

This won't be mattered in other modes well but as Taiko, there is already hitsounds like dons and kats. They will be affected by this and would have weird experience which cannot be handled by self.

So I say this as rule for Taiko ag least but not sure for other modes since they use keysounds sometimes.

Hm.

I don't think it happens often enough to warrant that. I think it used to happen more cause it was the default setting in lazer's editor, but i think that has since been changed

As it is fairly uncommon, any time it is used is already normally intentional by nature too on top of what Oko said. I'll be archiving this for now