DakeDekaane wrote: d4k5k

Nice song, I loved it~ x3 :3

[General]

Add lead-in time of 1 second at least. Sure, I forgot about this >.<

[Normal]
01:18:340 (2) - Move it to keep spacing 1.0x in this part. Fixed.

Leorda wrote: 6bp3m

[Normal]
00:07:883 (1) - Remove new combo for your combo pattern Ok.
01:32:398 (2) - Add clap at tail slider Oops, added.


[Hard]
00:05:998 (4) - Not stack correctly with previous notes (look at test mode for proof) Fixed.
00:19:540 (2) - Add finish at head sldier? Added, forgot this too.

Tsukasa wrote: 4w1b6w

Normal:

00:11:483 (4) - It'd be better if the start of the slider had the clap sound instead of a whistle sound. Just to keep the consistency of the hitsounds I like how that whistle sounds there.
00:30:683 (1) - ^same concept with the whistle sound. It'd be better if you kept it at soft normal sound A Clap on start of this slider sounds off of consistency.

Hard:
Nothing really major here. Though I'd advise you to look for a nazi modder

Insane:
AR 9 is too fast for a map/song like this. It'd be better IMO if it's kept to AR8 Hmm someone told me the same, if another person point this maybe I will change it.

-Bakari- wrote: 1r12o

[Normal]
clear \>.</ >w<

[Hard]
00:04:455 (2) - oh.. well. try to remove (3) and add reverse to (2) fits with music beter, imo Ok.
00:09:426 (1) - 1/2 longer? Sounds bad for me D:

[Insane]
00:39:083 (1,2,3,4,1) - you stack 1/2 notes and in next pattern you stack 1/4 notes. kinda hard to read :/ try to unstack 00:39:083 (1, 2) This isn't hard to read imo, it's easily visible.
00:44:740 (5) - nazi: try use same shape as on 00:45:426 (1) http://puu.sh/PJqB Why?, a different slider there is not bad at all.

Frostmourne wrote: 4k533o

Normal
01:34:455 (1) - after guitar solo , this should be finished so it will sound very nice :3 Uhm I didn't do it in other diffs, so I prefer to keep it without a Finish.
00:54:683 (6) - choose both whistle or finish here , I think it will be nice too ;o That note has a Finish o.o

Hard
00:03:598 (3,4) - why don't move these two notes to x:228 y:252 , more balance and looking good from this 00:01:883 (2) - Ok.

Insane
AR 9 is too high for me huh ok, reduced by 1.
00:41:312 (5) - I find it better to make slider here and end at (6) , it comes from my personal aspect that this jump will fit very well at this point Ok but I made a 1,5x jump instead a long one.

SPOILER

00:48:855 (5,1) - feel too short for me =_=a between here 1,5x also here fits good for me.

1. 00:54:699 (2) - center point to x:112 y:164

1. 00:14:569 (1) - remove NC here and NC on next note
2. 00:43:712 (1) - NC is not necessary
3. 01:15:255 (1,2) - make 1/2 slider instead?

1. 00:02:398 (1) - add whistle at the beginning
2. 00:47:740 (7) - unnecessary note
3. 00:54:683 (6) - add whistle at beginning
4. 01:14:912 (1) - remove NC
5. 01:25:883 (1) - ^

1. 00:05:312 (6) - whistle?
2. 00:41:312 (5) - makes the flow a little funny right now..make less curvy
3. 01:21:598 (3) - ^

meiikyuu wrote: 1t524m

...idk if its just me but i think all the notes are unsnapped. Timing -> Resnap All Notes . it will also correct hitsounds Yes, they are unsnapped, I forgot to snap them >_>

Normal

1. 00:14:569 (1) - remove NC here and NC on next note Ok.
2. 00:43:712 (1) - NC is not necessary Removed.
3. 01:15:255 (1,2) - make 1/2 slider instead? No.

Hard

1. 00:02:398 (1) - add whistle at the beginning Hmm, added in previous note, sounds better.
2. 00:47:740 (7) - unnecessary note That note fits nice with the music.
3. 00:54:683 (6) - add whistle at beginning Added Finish instead like other diffs.
4. 01:14:912 (1) - remove NC Ok.
5. 01:25:883 (1) - ^ ^

Insane

1. 00:05:312 (6) - whistle? I don't like how it sounds here, added in 5 instead.
2. 00:41:312 (5) - makes the flow a little funny right now..make less curvy Ok.
3. 01:21:598 (3) - ^ ^

Genkishi wrote: 663a6b

[General]
-Disable countdown Done.

[Normal]
00:06:014 (4) - Make the slider like this instead? http://puu.sh/QBH1 Ok.
00:58:471 (4) - 1 grid to the left Fixed.

[Hard]
01:44:740 (1) - Why is this slienced? Add a hitsound for this note It has a hitsound, notes were unsnapped, it's fixed now.

[Insane]
01:22:471 (4) - Move 1 grid to the left Fixed.

Beren wrote: 3m2p4o

[General]
2 .osb? remove it Ok.

[Normal]
00:23:671 (4) - ~00:25:728 (1) - add break Not necessary.
00:26:414 (4) - ~00:28:128 (1) - ^ ^
00:28:128 (1,2,3) - too hard in normal diff Hmm three stacked notes are not hard ._.
00:34:642 (4) - ~00:36:699 (1) - add break Not necessary.
00:37:385 (4) - ~00:39:099 (1) - ^ ^
00:39:099 (1,2,3) - same 00:28:128 (1,2,3) Not hard.


[Hard]
00:14:928 (3) - add finish There aren't Finish here in other diffs, so I won't add it.
00:23:671 (4) - ~00:25:728 (1) - add break Not necessary.
00:26:414 (4) - ~00:28:128 (1) - ^ ^
00:34:642 (4) - ~00:36:699 (1) - ^ ^
00:37:385 (4) - ~00:39:099 (1) - ^ ^
00:47:842 (1) - remove whistle add finish Ok
00:52:985 (7) - add note and clap Sounds a bit Ok.
01:09:785 (1) - add finish Ok.
01:20:756 (1) - ^ ^


[Insane]
00:05:328 (6) - end at 00:05:842 No.
00:23:671 (4) - ~00:25:728 (1) - add break Not necessary.
00:26:414 (4) - ~00:28:128 (1) - ^ ^
00:28:471 (3) - jump No.
00:34:642 (4) - ~00:36:699 (1) - add break Not necessary.
00:37:385 (4) - ~00:39:099 (1) - ^ ^
00:39:442 (3) - jump? No.
01:20:756 (1) - add finish Ok.
01:44:756 (1,2,3,4) - try square Ok.

Beren wrote: 3m2p4o

Hi/


[Easy]
00:23:156 (1) - too many turns
00:25:728 (1) - ^
00:34:128 (1) - ^
00:36:699 (1) - ^ Changed all those
01:08:756 (3) - move to 01:08:414
01:14:242 (3) - move to 01:13:899 no and no,
01:23:842 (1) - x:80 y:308 no

athiota33 wrote: 5p432w

[Normal]

00:11:499 (4) - Remove whistle in the begining? No, it's following vocal.
00:14:928 (5) - Add whistle? Ok.
00:28:471 (3) - Why 1/4? It's hard for player. Use 1/2 instead? Due that these notes are stacked I think is not really hard.
00:39:442 (3) - ^ ^
01:34:471 (1) - Add finish here? I can hear cymbal sound. Added a Whistle instead like my other diffs.

[Hard]

00:14:756 (1) - Remove clap? No.
01:34:471 (4) - Add finish? same reason as normal I'll keep Whistle.

[Insane]

Nice diff~

Gabe wrote: 4i6g6f

Normal

Circle emplacement

1. 00:02:928 (4) - This is mostly a suggestion. Having three 1/2 sliders is boring. I'm suggesting you to delete the circle (5) and scale the slider (4). Like this; Hmm I prefer to keep it as it is.
   Screenshot

   
   
2. 00:28:128 (1,2,3) - This was supprising. Having This is fine for me.

Hitsounds
Everything is consistent.

1. 00:07:556 - You could add a whistle here for the vocal. Yeah but I didn't want to follow vocal here.

Hard

Circle emplacement

1. 01:32:414 (2,3,4,5) - I like the spacing here but, it's 1,50x. Can you try to have the same scaping everywhere? A jump with 1,5x fits nice here with the music imo.
2. 01:44:756 (1,2,3,4) - This appears too soon after the spinner. Also, the spinner has some yellow on it, so it could confuse some players. Can you color hax it? For the spinner, end it at 01:44:071 like every other difficulties spinners. No, only Normal has a shorter spinner in my diffs, because would be hard if after a spinner suddenly appears a note, that's why I cutted it. I changed color.

Hitsounds

1. 00:03:099 - Add a whistle here since there's no objects at 00:02:928. Ok.

Insane

Circle emplacement

1. 00:05:156 (5,6) - This doesn't sounds good. Doing or sounds better with the vocal. Deleted 6.
2. 00:09:099 (8) - Can you move this to x:360 y:320 because the previous slider is curved and the two circles after it doesn't fit. Not necessary, fits nice for me.
3. 00:26:071 (2,3,4) - Move these circles anywhere in the gameplay. Not all stacked, please. Ok.
4. 00:36:699 (1,2,3,4) - Same as above. Ok.
5. 01:44:756 (1,2,3,4) - As mentionned on the Hard difficulty, color hax it to blue and end the spinner at 01:44:071. Only Changed colour.

• Settings

1. Deshabilita letterbox during breaks en todas las dificultades
2. 01:28:985 - El kiai time deberia terminar aqui.

• Beatmap Suggestions

1. 00:37:556 - Agrega otro break aqui para ser consistente con la parte anterior igual a esta.
2. 01:01:556 (1,2,1,2) - Realmente sugiero que sustituyas estos circles por sliders ya que a algunos rookie players se les puede complicar seguir el cambio de la secuencia entre 1/1~1/1 y 1/1~1 1/2, ademas de que en 01:02:756 (1) debes eliminar el new combo porque la secuencia musical de la pista es la misma y no muestra ninguna variante, similar a 01:37:214 (1,2).

• Beatmap Suggestions

1. 00:28:128 (1,2) - Preferiría sustituir los circles por un slider para hacer la diff mas fácil, si lo haces entonces en [Hard] sustituye el slider por dos circles, vaya! esta parte me pareció mas difícil a comparación de [Hard].
2. 00:39:099 (1,2) - Lo mismo que arriba, espero que lo cambies.
3. 01:28:299 (1) - Elimina el new combo, ahora agrega uno aquí 01:28:985 (6) y eliminalo en el siguiente slider.
4. 01:35:499 (4) - El new combo debería empezar aquí, ademas de que al hacerlo se tiene un patrón lindo (simétricamente hablando).

• Beatmap Suggestions

1. 00:47:671 (6) - Considero que seria mejor empezar el new combo aquí debido al triplete que se viene, como lo hiciste en 00:14:756 (1).
2. 01:16:471 (1) - Como en una observación que le puse a verdis deberías eliminar el new combo porque la secuencia musical es prácticamente igual y como no muestra algún cambio no es nada difícil seguir el patrón, además que no llevaste a cabo esa modificación con la parte similar a esta que esta atras 01:01:556 (1).
3. 01:22:642 (1) - Bien aqui si hay una razon para colocar un new combo, el ligero cambio en la voz cierto? okay, ese no es el punto, el punto es que aqui colocaste el new combo para remarcar esto pero en la secuencia anterior no lo hiciste pese a que es el mismo cambio de voz... 01:21:956 (4), ahora, no me gustaría ver dos new combos seguidos por la misma razon, así que mi solución seria agregar new combo en 01:21:956 (4) y eliminarlo en 01:22:642 (1).

• Beatmap Suggestions

1. 00:28:471 (3) - Al igual que 00:47:671 (6) en [Hard] sugiero empezar el new combo aqui, aunque el anterior se quede con solo dos beats.
2. 00:31:214 (5) - Lo mismo que arriba.
3. 00:39:442 (3) - Otra vez, recuerda que los puntos que no estan en negritas o en rojo no son forzosamente obligatorios pero realmente un poco importantes de ver y considerar.
4. 01:08:928 (3) - Ctrl+R para marcar un equilibrio en el espacio, recuerda que también debe existir este en el manejo de direcciones de sliders y circles, en este caso se trata de un slider y si te das cuenta el que sigue va hacia la derecha así que porque no marcarlo aquí también? por cierto, el flow se siente ligeramente mejor en esta parte si aplicas este cambio.

dubbadeni wrote: 2b3h2v

Normal

00:13:556 (3) - You didn't use distance snap with this slider. I did.
00:28:128 (1,2,3) - Maybe a bit too hard for normal? It's changed now.

Kenezz wrote: 203g67

[General]

• Settings

1. Deshabilita letterbox during breaks en todas las dificultades Hecho.
2. 01:28:985 - El kiai time deberia terminar aqui. Cierto, fixed.

[Normal]

• Beatmap Suggestions

1. 00:28:128 (1,2) - Preferiría sustituir los circles por un slider para hacer la diff mas fácil, si lo haces entonces en [Hard] sustituye el slider por dos circles, vaya! esta parte me pareció mas difícil a comparación de [Hard]. Ok, y en la Hard prefiero no hacer cambios porque lo veo bien.
2. 00:39:099 (1,2) - Lo mismo que arriba, espero que lo cambies. Ok.
3. 01:28:299 (1) - Elimina el new combo, ahora agrega uno aquí 01:28:985 (6) y eliminalo en el siguiente slider. Ok.
4. 01:35:499 (4) - El new combo debería empezar aquí, ademas de que al hacerlo se tiene un patrón lindo (simétricamente hablando). Ok.

[Hard]

• Beatmap Suggestions

1. 00:47:671 (6) - Considero que seria mejor empezar el new combo aquí debido al triplete que se viene, como lo hiciste en 00:14:756 (1). Ok.
2. 01:16:471 (1) - Como en una observación que le puse a verdis deberías eliminar el new combo porque la secuencia musical es prácticamente igual y como no muestra algún cambio no es nada difícil seguir el patrón, además que no llevaste a cabo esa modificación con la parte similar a esta que esta atras 01:01:556 (1). Creía que iba a ser un combo algo largo si no ponia el NC, pero bueh, ok.
3. 01:22:642 (1) - Bien aqui si hay una razon para colocar un new combo, el ligero cambio en la voz cierto? okay, ese no es el punto, el punto es que aqui colocaste el new combo para remarcar esto pero en la secuencia anterior no lo hiciste pese a que es el mismo cambio de voz... 01:21:956 (4), ahora, no me gustaría ver dos new combos seguidos por la misma razon, así que mi solución seria agregar new combo en 01:21:956 (4) y eliminarlo en 01:22:642 (1). Sip, queda mejor.

[Insane]

• Beatmap Suggestions

1. 00:28:471 (3) - Al igual que 00:47:671 (6) en [Hard] sugiero empezar el new combo aqui, aunque el anterior se quede con solo dos beats. Ok.
2. 00:31:214 (5) - Lo mismo que arriba. Ok.
3. 00:39:442 (3) - Otra vez, recuerda que los puntos que no estan en negritas o en rojo no son forzosamente obligatorios pero realmente un poco importantes de ver y considerar. Ok.
4. 01:08:928 (3) - Ctrl+R para marcar un equilibrio en el espacio, recuerda que también debe existir este en el manejo de direcciones de sliders y circles, en este caso se trata de un slider y si te das cuenta el que sigue va hacia la derecha así que porque no marcarlo aquí también? por cierto, el flow se siente ligeramente mejor en esta parte si aplicas este cambio. Si, se ve mejor, hecho.

Buena suerte, espero que esto te sirva de algo y por favor retírate de esto que lo haces pésimo ♥ Lo se, no me voy a retirar pero prometo seguir haciendote sufrir con mis mapas malos :333

ikari_kyon wrote: 1z673m

mod pa los taiko

[oni] x3j5r

cambia los dos cambios de custom soundset que tenes al default, es bastante inutil, cambialo no te cuesta nada ;3
lo mismo para los cambios de soundset a normal, es lo mismo que el cambio de volumen, innecesario Listoco

1. 00:04:985 (1,1) - me queda algo random esta parte, somo no hay mucho sonido musical, que tal dejarlo siguiendo el vocal, movelos a los anteriores ticks rojos respectivamente Suena y se juega bastante bien con eso
2. 00:08:242 (1) - el vocal no esta tan claro aca, sugerencia: hay un acorde de guitarra en aumento en 00:08:071, que tal mover este objeto aca y dejarlo en katsu? ok pero no al katsu
3. 00:28:299 (1) - finish? por la bateria y el bajo de esta parte
4. 00:50:842 (35,36) - la verdad no escucho nada que amerite un doble~ veo que tienes varios mas, y la verdad lo mismo no entiendo Suena bien esos dobles, mucho triple tambien aburre
5. 01:02:071 (100) - debido a 01:01:556 (98,99) - parece que queda suelto este K, agregar uno o dos don de 1/2 luego de este rellenaria el espacio y el finish no me suena tan suelto, tamb en 01:02:756 (101), 01:03:442 (102)nah, esto suena bien para mi :s
6. 01:15:442 (169) - ya que el tono de bajo suena casi igual, cambialo a un K por el anterior? no, pero le puse un d normal
7. 01:26:242 - debido al cambio de soundset este objeto y el siguiente spinner suenan demasiado altos comparado con los anteriores, una razon para usar solamente un soundset en todo el mapa

[musukachi] 52t4d

no deberian estar los diff settings en 5?okz

1. 00:28:985 (73) - esperaba un katsu o3o Poner un katsu ahi suena muy repetitivo
2. 01:09:442 (10) - ↑~ aqui pongo el kastu
3. 01:44:756 (1) - ~ creo que no hay problema si quitas el finish y haces 4 katsus de 1/2

y me gustaria que agregaras uno que otro triplet por ahi y por allanop, esta bien asi, me gusta mas como suena con los 2 finishs

y bueno nada si no te gusta el mod nada que hacer, don darsonic me pidio y bueh ;3

[Luanny PhNyx] wrote: 31s3s

yo verdi
[Muzukashii]
-Almost couldn't find anything D: Your diff is very well made
-HP/OD +1? OKAY
00:33:271 (91) - d here sounds cool, like you did on 00:41:671 (111,112,113,114,115) - . (91) sounds really similar to (92) so I don't see why it is a k. ok
01:09:442 (10) - k here flows better with the music. Your base on this map is d k d k, so this d on (10) is breaking your 'sequence' and doesn't even sound cool as a variation. ok
01:18:871 (40) - k here sounds cool imo
01:20:414 (47) - same as 01:09:442 (10)
01:22:985 (55,56) - either kk or dd sounds better here because you used kd twice before, making it sounds little repetitive and it kinda follow the background ok to all

[Oni]
-Change sample to Normal through the map. Soft is too low, I can barely hear or hitsounds here. Try Normal 80% if you don't want loud hitsounds. Also, your changes between N and S here are nonsense . changed ,3
-Why custom? You doesn't even have taiko-custom hitsounds in your song folder so it is useless.

00:14:756 - maybe add a k here? I feel a blanket here when playing. okay
00:16:471 (1,1,1) - maybe ddk or kdk here. 00:16:642 (1) - should be k because of your d k d k base. Variations are ok but not in this case, imo, but it is completely opitional and isn't wrong the way it is okay...
00:22:642 (1) - You can notice on the song that 00:22:642 - has a slight lower pitch, so d fits better here oks
00:41:156 (1,1,1) - same as 00:16:471 (1,1,1) No, with this pattern here i'm fine
00:58:471 (81) - k sounds better for me here. I don't know, d just sounds weird like there is something missing :s changeed
01:01:556 (98) - ....ok. Are you sure you're going to do that?

http://osu-ppy-sh.tvgratuite.org/wiki/Taiko_Ranking_Criteria
Well, it can be allowed but like 90% of the players hate it..
It fits well with the song and with the next patterns BUT to avoid a possible stress, you can delete 01:01:471 (97) - (sounds even better, imo) or let I just delete 01:01:471 - :3 01:01:556 (98) - just a k. Up to you :s
01:25:385 (219) - D here to keep following what you did on the previous patterns
01:33:271 (1,1,1) - yep, again.. orz

lol it was short
Good look \:3

AdRon Zh3Ro wrote: 106i3r

[Offset]
This is the correct one: No, it isn't. I used 1198 before but a MAT told me that offset wasn't right, and +17 will be nice. Verdi checked it and we decided that 1214 sounds nice.


[Insane]
00:21:599 (5,6) These two are in the correct spacing, yes. But they are too low, try to place them a bit more to the right. And since there is a break right after, it's easy to redo the spacing of the following notes. I think these notes are not a problem if they are too low since these are still in the screen.
00:26:227 (2) 3 ticks up looks better. Not necessary imo.
00:34:113 (1) This anti-jump is rather easy to miss-read. Put it farther, it'll not ruin the pattern.. Each person that tested this never had a problem with this pattern, so no changes.

Teru21 wrote: 6f5aw

your first kiai time here 01:07:042 and ended 01:15:271 right..? how bout ended it 01:17:671 ? more fit xD No, it ends before because the little change on the vocal.

[Normal]
I just recognize this.. copy "soft-sliderslide2" to another soft-sliderslide , etc.. the front is so noisy xD
01:22:813 (2) - not shaped well I won't change it if you don't give some suggestion.
01:37:214 (1) - 2 grid to the right? No, the middle point is in the center, so it's fine.

[Insane]
00:34:128 (1,2,3,4) - not shape well enough.. Same as before, no changes, and... this seems really fine o.o
01:22:642 (5) - Mustache lol xD :D

Darksonic wrote: 515a16

Teru21 wrote: 6f5aw

EDIT

[Normal]
01:22:813 (2) - not shaped well I won't change it if you don't give some suggestion. http://puu.sh/XYL5

[Insane]
00:34:128 (1,2,3,4) - not shape well enough.. Same as before, no changes, and... this seems really fine o.ohttp://puu.sh/XYPz

Teru21 wrote: 6f5aw

[Verdi's Easy]
imo, Clap hit sound on the 00:03:614 (5,1,1) - not that fit.. how bout adding whistle? after the music really starts, u can add Claps xD uhm no
00:02:756 - add note? no
00:21:614 (2) - not shaped well enoughit's fine
00:28:128 (1) - a bit hard to play.. only add circle 00:28:299 ? if you don't change then swap hit sound so 00:28:128 - finish and 00:28:299 - whistle. more fit like that xD really? it's just a 1/2 slider, it plays like a 1/1 slider
00:39:099 (1) - ^ ^
00:44:071 (3,1) - (3) not shaped well with (1) how bout (3) using 4 dots instead of 3? no

[Muzu]
00:02:414 (5) - k? NO
00:28:128 (71,72) - woohoo! again xD dK no
00:39:099 (103,104) - ^ no
00:28:985 (74) - k no
00:30:356 (79) - ^ no

[Oni]
00:08:928 (1,1,1) - kkk no >:
Yay xD Fun diff xD

Byakugan249 wrote: 1721s

a
[Verdi's Easy]
00:03:956 (1) - that finish at the beginning is too loud. reduce the volume to 40% so that it matches the volume in this part of the song.
00:05:328 (2) - ^ ^ ok
00:09:613 (1) - maybe it's just me, but i feel that this spinner doesn't belong here because the lyrics and instrumental are going for this part. i suggest doing something like this as it follows the vocals/instrumental nicely. if you ignore this, then you can come up with a similar pattern to what i suggested.I fix this in my way
00:16:985 - add a circle here. it'll be consistent with the blue (3) since the rhythm is the same. Nah, it's fine
00:23:499 - same as above, but it'll follow the drums in the song. ^
00:25:728 - consider adding something here for consistency with the other diffs in this part of the song. i suggest a 2/1 slider to follow the guitar in this part of the song. I prefer a break here x-x
00:34:128 (5) - here too. replace this for a 2/1 slider to follow the guitar. the sliderticks should follow the change in the guitar. ^
00:36:699 - same as 00:25:728. ^^^^^^
00:42:699 (2) - i suggest making the slider like this. if you look carefully, the gap between (4,2) are even and i think doing this would make the flow somewhat smoother as it's bordering (4) as you see here. I'm fine with the slider, so no
01:00:185 (2) - remove the finish at the beginning. i see that you're trying to follow the vocals, but the problem is that the vocals start 1/2 back and it sounds out of sync to the song. No, I like how the finish sounds here
01:04:299 (1) - reduce this spinner by 1/2 because that's where the vocals end and it makes me feel comfortable if it ends there. there's nothing here to follow but the hold in the cymbals from the 1/2 tick. nah, that would leave a "gap" between the spinner and (1)
01:22:128 (3) - remove the clap at the repeat arrow. it ruins the calm feeling in the vocals since the vocals fade out gradually.
01:23:842 (1) - extend this slider by 1/2 and add a finish at the end to emphasize the vocals and to follow the cymbals in the song. okk
01:30:699 (2) - i think that the flow would continue if you can make this slider look like (1), just point it at the opposite direction like this. uhm, no. I prefer it like it is

[Verdi's Taiko Muzukashii]
00:18:871 (52) - i'm feeling a K here because not only it plays nicely with the drums, but it plays nicely to the cymbals as well IMO. I don't like how the K sounds, so no
01:04:299 (1) - you can still hear the drums during the spinner. try doing D K K D. like this. it'll match the drums and the cymbals in this. if you ignore my suggestion, then you can come up with a different pattern, but the placement should be the same. OK

[Verdi's Taiko Oni]
00:20:928 (1) - a K should be here because of not only the drums, but the cymbals as well. I change this in my way
00:21:614 (1) - ^ ^^
00:22:299 (1) - instead of a k, make this a D. only the drums are played in this part. nah, I prefer que k here D:
01:26:414 (1) - i feel that this spinner doesn't fit with this part. you can still hear the drums in this part, so replace this spinner for a D/K pattern. i suggest doing K d K d D d D. i think this pattern plays nicely to the drum IMO. if you ignore this, then you can come up with a different pattern, but the placement should be the same. I made this in my way
01:32:071 (1) - a K should be here because of the cymbals. ok
01:37:728 (1) - same as 00:20:928.
01:38:414 (1) - ^
01:39:099 (1) - same as 00:22:299. No to those 3, sorry

Byakugan249 wrote: 1721s

[General]
2 taiko BGs? delete the one that doesn't have the "short ver" since you're not using it. Oops, done.

[Normal]
consider using that sliderslide file at the beginning. that sound in the slider really bothers me and it might bother other people as well. Yep, done.
00:02:928 (4) - Do Ctrl+J for this. if you notice (1,3,4) makes a triangle, continuing the flow to the next note during gameplay. it'll look like that this pattern is going around in a circle. Yeah seems better.
00:06:014 (4) - hmm...maybe you can add a whistle at the sliderbody to go along with the bass? Ok.
00:17:671 - 00:23:156 - consider using the code below. i just moved some notes around and make possible blankets which should make this part flow smoother during gameplay IMO. This is ok for me.

SPOILER

100,192,17671,6,0,B|132:240|132:240|132:292,1,110,4|8
100,336,18185,1,2
212,336,18528,1,2
288,260,18871,2,0,B|319:214|380:204,1,110,6|0
472,256,19556,2,0,B|504:200|472:148,1,110,6|0
452,100,20071,1,8
352,60,20414,6,0,B|296:92,1,55,4|0
196,100,20928,2,0,B|184:164|244:188,1,110,8|0
192,284,21614,2,0,B|244:304|302:284,1,110,8|0
344,184,22299,2,0,B|388:144|356:80,1,110,8|0
344,32,22814,1,8
300,128,23156,6,0,B|245:128,3,55

00:28:128 (1) - add a finish at the end. you can hear the cymbals when it hits this part of the slider. I don't like how Finish sounds here, that's because I didn't add it in my other diffs too.
00:28:471 (2) - replace this for a circle. i'm not hearing the drums at the beginning or at the repeat. i also feel that it'd be easier for players to clear during gameplay. That feels so empty imo D:
00:30:699 (1) - i think that the flow would be smoother if you can make this slider look like (3). even though the lyrics change, the transition from (3,1) plays oddly for me during gameplay as the movement ruins that smooth feeling to the map. Ok.
00:39:099 (1) - same as 00:28:128. No changes.
00:39:442 (2) - same as 00:28:471. No changes.
00:47:156 (4) - point this slider down like (2,3). it'll follow the melody in the vocals. pointing the slider at that direction breaks the flow to the map and a smooth feeling to the song. Ok.
01:00:871 (6) - add a clap at the beginning. it'll emphasize the snare drum in this part. Ok.
01:07:385 (1,2,3,4,5) - re-arrange the pattern like this. (2) would make a blanket for (5), and (3,4,5) would follow it up as it makes an oval shaped pattern, not only that, the end of (4) would be blanketed, and the end of (4,1,2) would make a triangle. the code is in the box if you wanna see. I like it, done.

SPOILER

400,104,67385,5,8
308,40,67728,2,0,B|256:16|200:40,1,110,0|8
112,104,68413,1,0
204,164,68756,2,0,B|256:188|312:164,1,110,0|8
400,104,69442,1,8

[Hard]
same comment as normal about the sliderslide file. Done.
00:06:013 (3) - ooh re-snap this slider. it's off by 1ms and same as normal about the whistle. Ok.
00:20:414 (1) - consider spacing this out a bit and moving it at the middle. and making the slider like this. i think that the flow would continue to the next note as this note is at the middle of the end of (2,3). they're technically acting as a blanket for this part. Ok.
00:42:185 (2) - *nazi* stack this note perfectly. the blanket looks weird when the note isn't stacked perfectly IMO, also (1,3) can be curved a lot smoother. the arc of the slider looks a bit too steep during gameplay. Moved 7,8 instead to fix that stack.
00:44:071 (5,7) - consider spacing these notes out so that it'd flow smoother to the song. it should make a diamond for this pattern like this. Seems better, done.
01:06:013 (5) - if you want to keep this pattern going, space this out and align it to (3) so that it'd be shaped like an oval. Ok.
01:06:185 (6) - if you follow the suggestion above, move this between (5) and at the end of (4) so that it'd make a triangle for this pattern. i think the flow would be smoother since the shape for this combo is complete. I stacked with the end of 4 instead.
01:20:413 (4) - i think that a jump should fit here since this vocal tone decreases and the next combo's melody increases again, so stack this on (2) if you apply this. I don't like how it seems so I prefer to keep this as it is.

[Insane]
same comment as normal about the sliderslide file. Done.
00:06:013 (6) - same as normal. Ok.
00:09:614 (2) - maybe you can add a clap here to go along with the guitar? Ok.
00:09:956 (3) - consider putting a curve on the straight part. it'll blanket (5), so basically, this slider is blanketing 2 notes in this part. like this. No because that would break the spacing here and I don't like how that seems.
00:20:242 (4) - put this on the left side of the pattern. it should look like a diamond like this. i also think that players would be expecting something like this during gameplay. Ok.
00:33:271 (1,2,3) - add claps at the 3 circles. it should emphasize the sound of the drums here. Sounds too loud for me.
00:53:671 (2) - flip this slider like this. the flow would be smoother than before since there's a gap when it reaches the curve IMO. Ok.
01:13:042 (2,3,4) - move these notes here. all of these notes would blanket (1) either way and i think the flow would be better because of that IMO. Yeah seems a lot better, done.
01:39:956 (1) - move this spinner up by 1/4 and add a circle. the circle follows the drums and guitar and the spinner follows it up. A note there sounds a bit bad imo.

BL-Daisuki wrote: 433fg

[Insane]

00:03:956 (1): Spacing error? Or this is intentional? Intentional.
00:19:385: Add a note with clap? Ok.
00:20:242 (5): Remove clap? No.
00:50:071 (3,4): CTRL+R, spacing looks better: http://puu.sh/Yh7z But a stack like that seems so easy and bored there.

00:45:956 (2,3): Maybe this can work: http://puu.sh/YgTz It doesn't fit for me.

[Hard]

HP-1 Nah, since Normal has HP 4, 6 is not really high for a Hard.

00:10:642 (4): Make slider similar to this? A curve slider seems awkward for me and don't follow previous slider in my opinion. http://puu.sh/YhfB Ok.

jonathanlfj wrote: 6k1j4w

[Normal]
00:06:014 (4) - put whistle on slider head too I don't like how it sounds.
00:19:556 (5) - do a copy paste of 00:17:671 (1) ? looks better imo It's ok for me.
00:28:128 (1,2) - kinda hard on normal...try this beat? You are showing a repeat and then slider, I made a slider and then repeat, what's the difference?

SPOILER

00:39:099 (1,2) - ^ ^
01:06:528 (5) - add a whistle to slider head Ok.
01:08:756 (4) - i think you flipped hitsounds here... Fixed.
01:26:242 (1,2,3) - adjust so it looks like this Ok.

SPOILER

01:34:471 (1) - add finish No.

[Hard]
00:04:471 (2) - make this a vertical flip of 00:03:956 (1) Ok.
00:06:013 (3) - add whistle (match with normal) I don't like how it sounds.
00:14:756 (1) - take off the clap? sounds awkward, or add clap to 00:14:842 (2) Oops, that Clap shouldn't be there, removed.
00:33:614 (5) - music suggest add a note here Ok.
01:02:071 (2,3,4,5,6,7) - try a moving pattern rather than stack? maybe a hexagon or back-and-forth movement Ok, changed it a bit.
01:06:528 (1) - whistle on slider head Ok.
01:15:271 (1,2) - bring this out of stack, it will confuse the timing of the next two notes which are also in stack I think this is fine.
01:15:785 (3,4,5,6,7) - its better if you make up a moving pattern here, especially of you don't want to bring the previous notes out of stack Not necessary imo.
01:26:756 (3,4) - separate these (or bring previous notes out of stack) ^
01:39:099 (6,7,8) - separate 6 with 7 and 8 (maybe put 7 and 8 in the center of the triangle?) I didn't do that but changed it.

[Insane]
since this is insane i wont spam anything about stacks (personally suck at reading stacks orz)
00:06:013 (6) - whistle on slider head I don't like how it sounds.
00:31:214 (1,2) - whistle sounds too loud...take it off? It fits nice with the guitar on the background.
00:57:956 (3) - 7 grids up for equal spacing It's ok in a Insane if sometimes spacing is a bit different on the same beat.
01:06:699 (3) - add a whistle here...feels better for some reason Sounds good for me without a Whistle.
01:09:785 (1) - add finish to slider head Done.
01:35:499 (11) - this note is too twisted, adjust a bit up and right Why? seems good.

DarkDunskin wrote: 5od4m

Hi~
Here's your requested Taiko Mod from King's Lair!

[Verdi's Taiko Oni]

1. 00:02:071 (1) - Add Clap? no
2. 00:02:756 (1) - ^ no
3. 00:02:928 (1) - Move that Note to 00:03:099 please. Its plays awful having empty space at that point if you follow the lyrics. No, i feel more comfortable how it is
4. 00:04:299 - Add Kat, make kd combo here. I don't like how that sounds
5. 00:04:985 (1) - Move that Note to 00:04:814 please.
6. 00:05:328 (1) - Move that Note to 00:05:156 please. no ^
7. 00:07:556 (1) - Add Clap? no
8. 00:08:071 (1,1) - Move them to the right red Ticks to follow the lyrics. Same as 00:02:928 (1) -
9. 00:09:614 (1) - Remove Finish, D D doesn't play good imo. Ok
10. 00:22:299 (1) - Remove Clap, add Finish. I prefer k here
11. 00:22:814 (1) - ^ ^
12. 00:39:185 (1,1) - Delete the left (1) and add Finish on the right (1). no x.x
13. 00:44:671 (1,1,1) - Delete surrounding notes, add Finish on the one in the middle. I don't like how this sounds
14. 00:55:385 (61) - Remove Finish. okk
15. 01:37:728 (1) - Add Finish, remove Clap.
16. 01:38:414 (1) - ^
17. 01:39:099 (1) - ^
18. 01:39:614 (1) - ^ no to all ^^^^^^^^

Rest looks good.
Just suggesting that you Map closer to the lyrics at the beginning since there is no drum-rythm.
[Verdi's Taiko Muzukashii]

1. 00:02:071 (4) - Add Clap? no
2. 00:02:928 (6,7) - Move them to the left red Ticks. Same answer as Oni
3. 00:04:985 (11,12) - ^
4. 00:08:414 (20,21) - ^ ^^
5. 00:11:156 (26) - Move that Note to the right red Tick.
6. 01:27:956 (70,71) - Move (70) on the right red Tick, delete (71). no and no ^^

Alright thats all.
I'd just really like to see you mapping closer to the lyrics at the beginning.
Good luck and have fun mapping~

SPOILER

1. You'd better change Taiko BG.png to .jpg
2. 01:15:271 - stopped kiai here is unnecessary i suppose, and also you didn't choose to stop kiai at 01:26:242 - where the music is same to prev. So i'd like to make it to be a whole kiai, or just place a small break at 01:17:842 - for second fountain.

1. I'd like to choose Slider Velocity 1 because extra tickpoint in short sliders like 01:25:556 (3) - are not ver suitable imo.
2. 00:42:699 (2,3) - these two slides are not looked good, make them more curved and symmetrical?
3. 01:30:356 - add a note here to maintain your beats consistant?
4. 01:33:099 - ^

1. I may choose to reduce hp or od by 1 because it looks hard a bit as a normal diff....
2. 00:06:014 (4) - highly recommend to remove the sliderwhislte sample on the slider.
3. 00:17:671 (1,2) - it may too hard for new players due to the high bpm, so i'd like to remove (2) and extend (1) to redtick
4. 00:19:556 (5,6) - ^
5. 00:22:299 (4,5) - ^, many similar patterns later which i worry about...
6. 00:28:471 (2) - should it be a 1/4 reverse slider? or, could it be instead by one note? still the difficulty issue ....
7. 00:39:442 (2) - ^
8. 00:51:442 (3,4,5) - maybe .. u can find a way to add those "missing claps" like make a clap sample as slidertick.wav and place a slider at appropriate place to fill that without a potential change of beat?
9. 00:54:699 (4,1) - similar to above, 2/4 clap is a good choice imo, so try to fill these claps into the diff
10. 01:00:871 (6) - remove head clap
11. 01:15:271 (1,2) - highly recommend to choose slider due to the difficulty issue.
12. 01:44:756 (1,2) - make one reversed slider here? difficulty issue.

1. 00:06:013 (3) - highly recommend to remove sliderwhistle
2. 00:43:042 (1,2,3,4) - may i know the reason of increasing spacing here? in my view, the music is going to low here, so reducing/consistant spacing may be better :>
3. 00:56:071 (3) - ctrl+r for better flow? (1) is from right to left, and then (2) left to right, so make it right to left may follow the sense :>
4. 00:56:756 (1,2) - if you agree with my suggestion above, it's better to press ctrl+h for them
5. 01:34:814 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - just a suggestion, i may choose to use kick sliders here for the music like:
   
   

1. recommend to reduce HP by at least 1 due to those long blanks where HP may reduce rapidly without restoring.
2. 00:06:013 (6) - remove sliderwhislte?
3. 00:22:642 (8,9) - make them away from (7) in order to avoid the misreading? just a sample
   
4. 01:32:242 (2,3,4,5,6) - to be honest the flow here is weird. when i test, my intuitive feeling is
   

Scorpiour wrote: 2pj3z

[General]

1. You'd better change Taiko BG.png to .jpg Is this really necessary?
2. 01:15:271 - stopped kiai here is unnecessary i suppose, and also you didn't choose to stop kiai at 01:26:242 - where the music is same to prev. So i'd like to make it to be a whole kiai, or just place a small break at 01:17:842 - for second fountain. This is ok as it is.

[Normal]

1. I may choose to reduce hp or od by 1 because it looks hard a bit as a normal diff.... Ok HP reduced.
2. 00:06:014 (4) - highly recommend to remove the sliderwhislte sample on the slider. It sounds nice with the bass.
3. 00:17:671 (1,2) - it may too hard for new players due to the high bpm, so i'd like to remove (2) and extend (1) to redtick This is not too hard for a Normal, that new players play mostly Easy diffs and not Normal xD.
4. 00:19:556 (5,6) - ^ ^
5. 00:22:299 (4,5) - ^, many similar patterns later which i worry about... ^
6. 00:28:471 (2) - should it be a 1/4 reverse slider? or, could it be instead by one note? still the difficulty issue .... ^
7. 00:39:442 (2) - ^ ^
8. 00:51:442 (3,4,5) - maybe .. u can find a way to add those "missing claps" like make a clap sample as slidertick.wav and place a slider at appropriate place to fill that without a potential change of beat? Since Verdi has another Clap in his diff I can't use a slidertick, so I'll keep this as it is.
9. 00:54:699 (4,1) - similar to above, 2/4 clap is a good choice imo, so try to fill these claps into the diff ^
10. 01:00:871 (6) - remove head clap Ok.
11. 01:15:271 (1,2) - highly recommend to choose slider due to the difficulty issue. No changes.
12. 01:44:756 (1,2) - make one reversed slider here? difficulty issue. ^

[Hard]

1. 00:06:013 (3) - highly recommend to remove sliderwhistle It sounds nice with the bass.
2. 00:43:042 (1,2,3,4) - may i know the reason of increasing spacing here? in my view, the music is going to low here, so reducing/consistant spacing may be better :> I increased distance on Insane for this part too because it fits for me, so I'll keep this as it is.
3. 00:56:071 (3) - ctrl+r for better flow? (1) is from right to left, and then (2) left to right, so make it right to left may follow the sense :> Ok.
4. 00:56:756 (1,2) - if you agree with my suggestion above, it's better to press ctrl+h for them Ok.
5. 01:34:814 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - just a suggestion, i may choose to use kick sliders here for the music like: No changes.
   
   

[Insane]

1. recommend to reduce HP by at least 1 due to those long blanks where HP may reduce rapidly without restoring. 7 is low enough D:
2. 00:06:013 (6) - remove sliderwhislte? No.
3. 00:22:642 (8,9) - make them away from (7) in order to avoid the misreading? just a sample Nah, not necessary imo.
   
4. 01:32:242 (2,3,4,5,6) - to be honest the flow here is weird. when i test, my intuitive feeling is Hmmm no.
   

Scorpiour wrote: 2pj3z

[Verdi's Easy]

1. I'd like to choose Slider Velocity 1 because extra tickpoint in short sliders like 01:25:556 (3) - are not ver suitable imo. This is not very necessary imo
2. 00:42:699 (2,3) - these two slides are not looked good, make them more curved and symmetrical? Those slider are fine
3. 01:30:356 - add a note here to maintain your beats consistant?
4. 01:33:099 - ^ I want to keep the rhythm how it is ^

Chewin wrote: 8364l

[Verdi's Easy]
everything fixed

[Verdi's Taiko Muzukashii]

00:59:328 add don I'm not following the voice here
00:59:499 (174) - remove Sounds strange for me
00:59:842 (175) - don ^
01:00:356 (177) - don ^
01:01:042 (181) - remove Same as 00:59:328
Following all my suggestions above
01:00:014 (175,176,177,178,179,180) - d k d k d k would sound better Same as Same as 00:59:328, sorry :s

Chewin wrote: 8364l

[General]

Add Sony, Theme, Kanae Aoki, Daisuke Achiwa to the tags and remove the 3 because it's useless. Added.

[Normal]

00:06:014 (4) - You should move this slider further from (3). Beginners would think it's just 1/1 since you used the same spacing of 00:04:471 (2,3) Ok.
00:53:156 (1) - There should be a circle with a finish on 00:53:328, then, what about to follow this rhythm? Adding a clap on 00:53:671 (2) too obv: Ok, sounds good.

01:02:756 (2) - Wrong hitsound here? I guess yes xD Remove this whistle Oops, my mistake, removed.
01:04:299 (1,2) - Finishes on these 2 sliders' heads. They'd emphasize the cymbals in the song Ok.
01:05:156 (3,4) - ^ This time on sliders' ends tails ;P Ok.
01:06:528 (5) - New combo according to the new sound? Removing NC from here 01:07:385 (1) would be better Added NC, but didn't remove the one from the next note.
01:34:128 (4) - To emphasize the cymbals in the song it'd be better if you remove clap using finish instead ;3 Added Finish.

[Hard]

00:07:728 (3,4) - Improve the blanket :\ Done.

SPOILER

416,116,7728,1,2
468,68,7899,2,0,B|500:104|488:152|456:176|456:176|456:204,1,140

00:20:928 (2,3,4) - Mh you should remove all claps from these sliders' starts adding finish to match the cymbals instead, it's much better I think these notes sounds good enough with Claps only.
00:41:671 (1,3) - Make them with more love çç I didn't want to use a different spacing there, but well, seems better like you did, done.

SPOILER

196,80,41671,6,0,B|224:40|292:40|316:84,1,140,2|8
256,128,42185,1,0
316,172,42356,2,0,B|292:216|224:216|196:176,1,140,2|8

00:53:156 (1) - This slider doesn't fit the song. You should use a circle here adding a slider with finish on 00:53:328 that follows the vocal: Ok.


[Insane]

00:06:013 (6) - I think this whistle sounds too loud D: remove it? It's nice following the bass, there is a whistle there in my other diffs.
01:32:756 (5) - I'd move this circle to x:464 y:204 to have a better triangle between 01:32:414 (3,4,5) I improved this pattern in a different way.
01:34:899 (4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11) - What about to edit this stream's shape in this way? It's more flowing to play: I prefer the way I did.

SPOILER

272,260,94899,1,0
232,240,94985,1,2
216,200,95071,1,0
232,164,95156,1,2
272,144,95242,1,0
316,164,95328,1,2
364,160,95414,1,0
388,112,95499,1,10

1. I had tested the offset again and found that offset: 1209 fit the song very well as it spot on very drum spot. (I got 0~2ms late when using this offset.)

1. 00:01:214 (1) - I would change this to don if I were you because the vocal pitch here is same as 00:01:556 - , so make it to kat for consistency.
2. 00:02:928 (6,7) - I would suggest moving 00:02:928 (6) - to 00:03:099 - and then remove (7)- because I can see you are following the vocal in this part, so you can also put a note at 00:02:756 - if you like.
3. 00:07:385 (16,17) - How about changing these to kat so that it can make a contrast with 00:01:899 (3,4) - .
4. 00:08:414 (19) - Same as 00:02:928-
5. 00:19:214 (x) - I would a note here sounds cool.
6. 00:28:128 (70,71) - I would suggest dk here if you want to follow the drum sound, kd is quite weird for me.
7. 00:28:985 (73) - A kat here?
8. 00:30:356 (78) - ^Add a kat here if you change previous suggestion.
9. 00:39:099 (102,103) - Same as 00:28:128
10. 01:13:728 (28) - I think big kat here fits the song better because the pitch at 01:14:414 (29) - is lower than here, so kat here can make a contrast with (29)-
11. 01:27:956 (70,71,72) - Please remove the finish here if poiisble because there are no any kind of finish or extremely strong emotions, so I don't think finish can fit the song well.
12. 01:32:071 (84) - A finish could be added here because of the accent from background music.

1. 00:01:214 (1) - Same as muzu.
2. 00:07:385 (1,1) - ^
3. 00:08:928 (1,1,1) - I don't think a triplet fits the music here because there are no drum sounds present there, only have guitar's protraction is not enough for fitting the triplet.
4. 00:11:156 (1,1,1) - Neither accent nor strong emotions present here, so remove the finish is the best way to fit the music.
5. 00:19:728 (1,1,1,1) - d ddk here sounds nice to me.
6. 00:28:128 (1,1) - Same as muzu, d K would be nice here.
7. 00:42:528 (1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1) - I wanna to say these triplet don't fit the music that much. I prefer simple 1/2 here.
8. 00:44:414 (1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1) - hum, what does this stream follows? I'm sure they follow neither drums nor vocal.
9. 01:17:671 (172) - Same as 00:11:1560- remove the finish would be nice or even change it to kat if you want.

kanpakyin wrote: 366t19

Taiko mod here:

[Timing]

1. I had tested the offset again and found that offset: 1209 fit the song very well as it spot on very drum spot. (I got 0~2ms late when using this offset.)

[Verdi's Taiko Muzukashii]

1. 00:01:214 (1) - I would change this to don if I were you because the vocal pitch here is same as 00:01:556 - , so make it to kat for consistency. Don sounds better than kat here, I'll skip this
2. 00:02:928 (6,7) - I would suggest moving 00:02:928 (6) - to 00:03:099 - and then remove (7)- because I can see you are following the vocal in this part, so you can also put a note at 00:02:756 - if you like. okay
3. 00:07:385 (16,17) - How about changing these to kat so that it can make a contrast with 00:01:899 (3,4) - .ok
4. 00:08:414 (19) - Same as 00:02:928- <:
5. 00:19:214 (x) - I would a note here sounds cool. ye
6. 00:28:128 (70,71) - I would suggest dk here if you want to follow the drum sound, kd is quite weird for me. dk sounds strange for me
7. 00:28:985 (73) - A kat here? no thx
8. 00:30:356 (78) - ^Add a kat here if you change previous suggestion. ^
9. 00:39:099 (102,103) - Same as 00:28:128 Same answer
10. 01:13:728 (28) - I think big kat here fits the song better because the pitch at 01:14:414 (29) - is lower than here, so kat here can make a contrast with (29)- I prefer the big don here
11. 01:27:956 (70,71,72) - Please remove the finish here if poiisble because there are no any kind of finish or extremely strong emotions, so I don't think finish can fit the song well. okay
12. 01:32:071 (84) - A finish could be added here because of the accent from background music. Sure

[Verdi's Taiko Oni]

1. 00:01:214 (1) - Same as muzu. no thanks D:
2. 00:07:385 (1,1) - ^ ^
3. 00:08:928 (1,1,1) - I don't think a triplet fits the music here because there are no drum sounds present there, only have guitar's protraction is not enough for fitting the triplet. Triplet deleted <:
4. 00:11:156 (1,1,1) - Neither accent nor strong emotions present here, so remove the finish is the best way to fit the music. okay
5. 00:19:728 (1,1,1,1) - d ddk here sounds nice to me. Ye, d ddk sounds better
6. 00:28:128 (1,1) - Same as muzu, d K would be nice here. Sounds strange for me D:
7. 00:42:528 (1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1) - I wanna to say these triplet don't fit the music that much. I prefer simple 1/2 here. okay
8. 00:44:414 (1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1) - hum, what does this stream follows? I'm sure they follow neither drums nor vocal. stream deleted
9. 01:17:671 (172) - Same as 00:11:1560- remove the finish would be nice or even change it to kat if you want. sure

Good luck.

Darksonic wrote: 515a16

No mod for me ?

BeatofIke wrote: 68633

lol don't worry, my mod will appear soon.

pieguy1372 wrote: 5n6l

General:

-maybe copy soft slidertick and use that in place of normal slidertick? since for this song, normal slidertick seems a bit loud IMO Nah, it's ok for me.

Normal: fine

Hard:

01:15:271 (1,2,3,4) - maybe it's a bit confusing, since for (1,2) it's a 1/2 note, but for (3,4), it's not o.o I think this is not confusing in a Hard diff.
01:26:242 (1,2,3,4) - same as 01:15:271 (1,2,3,4) I think this is not confusing in a Hard diff.

Insane: fine orz

BeatofIke wrote: 68633

Normal
00:28:128 (1,2) - I'm a bit iffy about this pattern. It doesn't look like a novice player would sight read that. Changed it.
00:45:785 (2,3,4) - You should make these sliders equally spaced. It flows with the music better. That's the best I can do due to the spacing.
01:00:871 (6,1) - Bad polarity here. I don't know what you mean.

Hard
-> Looks fine.

Insane
00:09:956 (3,4) - Try to see if you can blanklet this better. Done.

Melophobia wrote: 3z2i5w

[General]
Easy and Taiko Muzukashii have different tags. please make them the same in all diffs My mistake, fixed.
the size of the video file is too big. would be best if you could make it less than 10MB Hmm, I will see this later.
also, video offset should be 300 or so

[Insane]
00:28:299 - soft finish is better here Ok.
00:33:356 (2,3,4) - claps would be great here Yeah, sounds good.
00:33:785 (5) - i dont think finish+clap sounds that good. it's better to remove clap Ok.
00:39:271 (2) - soft finish will fit music best Ok.
00:44:328 (2,3) - claps Ok.
00:44:756 - finish here instead of clap Ok.
00:47:842 (3,4) - looking a bit messy imo. can you make them more symmetrical? Done.
01:01:556 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - soft sampleset is better here imo. refer to this diff if you like~ Yeah, sounds nice.
http://puu.sh/12Lma
01:28:642 (3) - finish Ok.

[Hard]
00:28:299 - soft finish is better here Ok.
00:33:442 - 00:33:614 - add claps Ok.
00:39:271 - soft finish here~ Ok.
00:44:756 (8) - add finish here instead of clap Ok.
00:44:328 - 00:44:414 - add claps Ok.
01:01:556 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - same as Insane Ok.
01:28:642 (3) - finish Ok.
01:32:071 - ^ Ok.

[Normal]
HD4 works well and will be more consistent with other diffs. Ok.
00:28:299 - i'd prefer soft finish here ==/ I changed this pattern before you modded it, so now can't add a Finish here.
00:33:442 (5) - clap? Ok.
00:33:785 (6) - finish~ Ok.
00:36:699 (1) - ^ Sounds bad imo.
00:44:756 - ^ Ok.
01:02:071 (1,2,3) - same as Insane Ok.
01:32:071 (1) - finish Ok.
01:34:471 (1) - ^ No.

pieguy1372 wrote: 5n6l

Verdi's Easy:

00:09:956 (3,4,5) - add finish on start? or do something like in Normal diff Okay

Melophobia wrote: 3z2i5w

Hi~


[Easy]
00:09:956 - finish sounds nice here
00:10:642 - ^
00:44:756 - ^ no thanks
01:28:985 (4,1) - switch these newcombo due to the end of kiai time? na
01:32:071 - finish
01:34:128 - ^
01:36:356 - ^ no, no and no, same answer as 00:44:756
01:40:128 (1) - this spinner should start at 01:39:956 - or 01:40:299 - because it appears sooner than 01:39:956 - and may be confusing for beginners. Okay
catchy hitsound xD but works very well and sounds good

-[NYAN]- wrote: 1y3l15

General

please delete (Short ver.). No, (Short ver.) can be used again.

Normal

00:34:814 - add break time Not necessary since there are only 2 segs without notes.
00:37:556 - ^

Hard

perfect！


Insane

00:26:071 (2) - NC No, it's the same sound as before.
00:37:042 (2) - NC ^
01:16:985 (5) - whistle Doesn't fit imo.
01:37:728 (3) - nc No, it's the same sound as before.

Konei wrote: 451331

[Normal]

00:12:185 (4) - the finish on end could be louder imo Sounds fine for me.
00:18:871 (4) - Make it look like 1? Gives a more familar shape Ok.
01:22:814 (2) - I think you could pretty up this slider, you other sliders with this shape looks nicer~ I rotated it a bit more to make it look nicer.


[Hard]

00:44:756 (8) - This note is a bit hard to read due to the many hitbursts~ Not a big problem imo due this is a Hard diff.
01:08:928 (6) - Should have the same shape as 1 imo~ Ok.
01:20:414 (4) - This stack doesn't play good imo, unstacking it may be good~ Ok.


[Insane]

00:06:014 (6) - reduce the volume of this whistle a bit?~ Nah, this has same volume as my other diffs.
01:37:728 (3,4) - This stack is a bit irritating with hidden, maybe unstack?~ No, fits better with the previous stacked notes.

NatsumeRin wrote: 2v6x1m

[General]
plz consider to remove those short breaks. You're trying to stress the drum sound, not there should be a break... Ok...

[Normal]
00:33:956 - add a note? Hmm I think there isn't a sound that would fit with a note, and also makes it a little Hard for a Normal, so I prefer to don't add it.
01:06:528 (1) - http://puu.sh/15UQF ? now it feels strange Changed.

[Hard]
HP-1 Ok.
00:33:099 (4) - http://puu.sh/15USk now from the curve to the end is too short, plus you're stacking notes, it may be a bit ugly. Changed it a bit.

[Insane]
01:05:842 (1,2,3) - http://puu.sh/15UTJ maybe. this is similar with the previous group, i don't see the need to totally change the direction... Seems bored imo if it's following the same direction, so I prefer to keep this as it is.
01:17:842 & 01:17:928 - add notes? Can't hear something that can fit with notes here D: